Select Page

Lawmakers weigh proposal to allow medical aid in dying in Illinois

Lawmakers weigh proposal to allow medical aid in dying in Illinois

Lawmakers heard testimony last week on whether to allow Illinois adults near death to medically end their own lives.

The Senate Executive Committee held a subject matter hearing Friday on a plan from Sen. Linda Holmes, D-Aurora, that would allow qualified patients with a terminal disease to request a physician prescribe aid-in-dying medication that would end the patient’s life “in a peaceful manner.”

Qualified patients must be at least 18 years old, have a diagnosis of a terminal disease that will likely result in death within six months and be deemed mentally competent. Two witnesses must sign off on the request for the lethal medication, and the patient must self-administer the dose.

Holmes said the language is similar to the law in Oregon, which has allowed the practice since 1997. Ten states and the District of Columbia have similar laws.

She told the committee that the bill has guardrails in place to prevent abuse of the law, including that at least one witness cannot be related to the patient or financially gain from the death.

A physician may also require a physiological evaluation if they suspect the patient may not have the capacity to make the decision. Physicians also have no obligation to offer the service.

Holmes and supporters said that the bill is not legalizing assisted suicide, stressing that those who choose the option are near death and often do not want to die.

“My question to those that are opposed is, ‘Why are you not allowing me the option to choose what I need to do in my life?’” Holmes said. “Why if I unfortunately get cancer, like both of my parents, and die? Why are you not leaving an option like this for me to alleviate my suffering at the end?”

Advocates shared personal experiences of family members who suffered at the end of their lives, including one whose family member stayed in California to receive treatment and medical aid in dying rather than move back home to Illinois.

Dr. Diana Barnard, a Vermont-based physician focused on hospice and palliative care, said in the decade-plus since the practice has been legal in her state, most people do not choose medical aid in dying until they’ve exhausted all other medical options.

“What we are trying to offer here is one additional tool that will be helpful for some part of the population,” Barnard said.

Dr. Peter Jaggard, an Evanston-based geriatrician, questioned the requirement for qualifying individuals to have a terminal disease, saying some terminally ill patients can live for several years beyond their prognosis.

He also opposed a requirement that any physician who objects to administering the service refer the patient, saying it contradicts the idea that physicians with a moral obligation can opt out.

Dr. Benjamin German, a Chicago-based primary care physician, said he worries that patients will be pressured or coerced into seeking such care by friends or family members. Additionally, he said there’s nothing in the law to stop a patient from “shopping” around with different doctors until they find one who will grant them medical aid in dying.

“A picture has been painted so far today that only the people to choose this would be those who have exhausted all their treatment options, have a clear and unhindered desire to live, and have symptoms that cannot be sufficiently relieved by pain treatment with palliative care,” German said. “But in real life, it’s not so clear cut.”

Other opponents raised concerns there were not enough safeguards to protect those with disabilities, saying that some physicians or family members may push those patients toward medical aid in dying over more expensive and complicated treatments.

Others said lawmakers should instead support hospice patients and workers to give individuals “dignity” at the end of their lives.

“I have a problem with the vulnerable people, those that we’re putting at risk by allowing active participation in death, and by allowing doctors and the government to essentially decide who dies,” said Dr. Kevin Garner, a hospice & palliative medicine internist in Granite City.

Committee Chair Sen. Cristina Castro, D-Elgin, said she struggled to understand why some individuals want to stop the choice for the “very narrow folks who qualify for (the bill).”

“This is for people who are very ill, who are going to die anyway, who want the choice,” she said.

About The Author